Antoniy, a Betis forward, was sent off late in the match against Getafe in La Liga matchday 25 (2-1), causing considerable controversy. The debate centers not only on the referee’s decision itself but also on who made it and its implications.
Referee Javier Alberola Rojas initially intended to caution the Brazilian player. However, following a discussion with assistant referee Miguel Martinez Munuera, Rojas issued a straight red card, dismissing the forward. Video Assistant Referee (VAR) Juan Martinez Munuera, Miguel’s brother, did not intervene.
In Spain, questions arose about a potential conflict of interest. One brother effectively removed Antoniy from the game, while the other, as VAR, chose not to overturn the decision.
It’s worth noting that while Alberola Rojas’s decision is indeed debatable, VAR intervention wasn’t mandatory because the referee didn’t commit a clear and obvious error. The significant attention surrounding this incident is largely due to the fact that Antoniy, who has been in good form, will now miss the match against Real Madrid. Real Madrid has recently been vocal about refereeing decisions and perceived bias. Betis has appealed the suspension and is trying to ensure their player is not disqualified.
Regarding conflicts of interest and family ties in refereeing, similar instances have occurred in the Russian league. Brothers Safyan, Dmitry (assistant referee) and Roman (AVAR or reserve referee), have been part of the same officiating team.
Vihaan Mehrotra