Manchester United’s Goalkeeper Crisis: Is Youth the Answer?

Manchester United find themselves in a familiar predicament as questions linger over their first-choice goalkeeper. Just two years after Erik ten Hag replaced long-serving David de Gea with Andre Onana, the position remains unsettled.

While some may regret De Gea’s departure, his final season was marred by costly errors, including a poor performance in Seville and a crucial mistake in the FA Cup final. Replacing him was arguably the right call, but Onana has failed to inspire confidence.

The Cameroonian keeper has committed more errors leading to goals than any other Premier League goalkeeper this season. His performance in the recent 2-2 draw with Lyon, where he was at fault for both goals, may have been the final straw.

Manager Ruben Amorim attempted to shake things up by starting Altay Bayindir against Newcastle, but the Turkish goalkeeper struggled in his Premier League debut. Bayindir looked uncomfortable with the ball at his feet and made a crucial error leading to Newcastle’s fourth goal.

With veteran Tom Heaton set to depart and both Onana and Bayindir failing to impress, could United turn to their academy for a solution? Young Elyh Harrison, who impressed during a loan spell at Chester earlier this season, may be worth considering.

The 19-year-old kept seven clean sheets in 18 games for Chester, earning high praise from his manager. While throwing Harrison into the first team would be a bold move, his performances suggest he could be ready for the challenge.

As United look to secure their future between the posts, giving Harrison a chance could prove to be a masterstroke. With nothing to lose, Amorim may decide it’s time to put his faith in youth once again.