Most Underrated Player from Each Premier League Club in 2024/25

While superstars like Erling Haaland and Mohamed Salah grab headlines, every Premier League squad has unsung heroes who quietly contribute to their team’s success. These underrated players may not receive as much recognition, but their importance cannot be overstated.

Let’s take a look at the most underrated player from each Premier League club for the 2024/25 season:

Arsenal – Jurrien Timber

Despite a rocky start due to injury, Jurrien Timber has become a key figure for Arsenal thanks to his versatility. Whether playing center-back, left-back or right-back, the Dutchman consistently delivers solid performances. While William Saliba and Gabriel often receive more praise, Timber’s reliability has been crucial for the Gunners this season.

Aston Villa – John McGinn

John McGinn embodies Aston Villa’s success under Unai Emery with his work ethic, tactical intelligence and leadership. The Scottish midfielder’s relentless pressing, ball-carrying skills and knack for scoring important goals make him indispensable. There’s a reason Villa fans sing about him being “better than Zidane”.

Bournemouth – David Brooks

David Brooks’ comeback from Hodgkin lymphoma has been remarkable. The Welsh winger has re-established himself as a creative force for Bournemouth with his wicked left foot and exquisite technique. His goal against Everton in December showcased his quality and reminded everyone of his talent.

Brentford – Yoane Wissa

While Bryan Mbeumo gets most of the plaudits, Yoane Wissa has been nearly as prolific for Brentford. The DR Congo international may not be as flashy, but he’s a superb finisher with pace and clever movement. Wissa’s contributions often fly under the radar despite being a handful for defenders.

Brighton – Danny Welbeck

Though no longer Brighton’s first-choice striker, 34-year-old Danny Welbeck brings calmness and intelligence to the Seagulls’ attack. His hold-up play, vision and ability to bring teammates into the game make him valuable, especially when Brighton need control in the final third.

Chelsea – Malo Gusto

While Reece James remains Chelsea’s star right-back, Malo Gusto has impressed when called upon. The young Frenchman’s defensive solidity and attacking threat have made him a reliable option. Gusto’s performances suggest he could be Chelsea’s long-term solution at the position.